The lessons of QVC vs Donn Edwards

Author: admin  |  Category: I say

I wrote about this recently You can read “Is calling people and telling them they have won a prize a scam?” to see what I had to say about the QVC scam. Today I don’t want to talk about the facts or even the insinuations I want to talk about customer service. You can read about the dangers of the silent customer here.

Donn Edwards is not a silent customer. He complained loudly about the waste of his time, when he found out that the so called prize he had definitely won was not to be, He asked to be removed from the call lists and was ignored. Donn took it a step further and complained on his blog about his impressions of QVC (Quality Vacation Club).

QVC chose to ignore Donn until they decided to sue for R 461 500. Donn wrote about it on his Blog. At this point I I were the MD of QVC, I would have gone out and bought Donn a car. I would have apologised publically and I would have ensured that the telesales team were instructed never to lie to a potential customer again.

I would further have legitimised my prize draws and told people you need to attend a sales presentation to qualify for the car draw. Not you have won. I would have set up a set of rules and guidelines that said that every 3 months we will be giving someone a car and made sure that the system was transparent.

QVC chose to sue Donn Edwards and got the blogging community up in arms. QVC have not just had an article that a few 100 people might have read and said so what. We all know it’s a scam and we ignore the calls and tell the telesales demons to go away, some less politely than others. We know there is no free lunch unless you are seriously gullible.

We know that Timeshare sales people are about as ethical as used car sales people. Yes I know I am generalising and that there are two or three very ethical used car salesmen out there. We know these things and most of the bloggers read Donns blog and said so what.

Here is the thing most bloggers are reasonably erudite and can tell their arse from their elbow. QVC’s attack on Donn was interpreted as an attack on Blogging. Now most bloggers have at least 4 readers, some have more. But facts are that blogs are a powerful medium and if you want negative publicity, attack the blogging world and I know that Bloggers know people in radio, on TV, in fact some bloggers are from the press.

So what happens in blogland does not stay in blog land. QVC have had a huge amount of unwelcome publicity because they were to arrogant to apologise. QVC have now had millions hear about Donn’s pretty sad experience of customer service.

QVC now have the general public aware of their dismal service record as seen on Hello Peter. Their negative publicity will cost them far more than fixing the problem would have.

Check out the facebook page an support Donn’s cause.

More on this subject

Tags: , , ,

No Responses to “The lessons of QVC vs Donn Edwards”

  1. Rox (12 comments.) Says:

    Brilliant post, Guy.

    This whole QVC drama has really been interesting, and a huge lesson for corporate companies to learn about customer service. One can only hope that QVC retreat with their tails between their legs and their reputation in shatters, and that similar ‘ventures’ think their operations through a little more carefully.

    But… from what we have seen of this company, they don’t seem like the type to admit defeat too easily. I just don’t see how they could possibly win on any levels, the whole thing has blown up in their faces so hugely.

    Roxs last blog post..This International Human Rights Day…

  2. Stii (1 comments.) Says:

    “At this point if I were the MD of QVC, I would have gone out and bought Donn a car. I would have apologised publically and I would have ensured that the telesales team were instructed never to lie to a potential customer again.”

    Dude, if they’d done this it would have turned the bad publicity from Donn into the most brilliant PR money could buy! But, ja, they screwed it up.

    Stiis last blog post..Mob rules – Taxi protest in Cape Town

  3. Douglas Says:

    Absolutley unf*****ing believable.

  4. Wizzard Says:

    Timeshare is one form of business that do not receive any of my money – simply because they have to resort to deceit to sell their ’services’.

    If the institutors of the lawsuit had any decency, they would drop the legal proceedings, apologize to the blogger and compensate him financially.

    But, I doubt that they would.
    We are engulfed by a sea of false advertising and false promises, and our judicial system seems indifferent.
    Even the ASA don’t answer emails reporting advertising fraud.

  5. Global Voices Online » Lessons on libel: South African blogger sued for defamation Says:

    [...] as a case against all bloggers in South Africa rather than just a personal attack. According to Guy McLaren: QVC’s attack on Donn was interpreted as an attack on Blogging. Now most bloggers have at least [...]

  6. Phumlani Diko Says:

    The most proactive and decent act for the MD would be to buy a car, secondly apologise for the inconsistances in the whole scundal and obvious train your sales team not to lie, misrepresent the content or over sell.

    Other the whole exersize will fuel bad publicity, attract unneccessary legal cost which might still lead the the sum still needing to be paid.

  7. Lessons on libel: South African blogger sued for defamation | Internet Filtering Monitor Says:

    [...] as a case against all bloggers in South Africa rather than just a personal attack. According to Guy McLaren: QVC’s attack on Donn was interpreted as an attack on Blogging. Now most bloggers have at least 4 [...]

  8. Errol N Says:

    About 3 weeks ago, I too was seduced to a presentation. The telemarketer who called me assured me that this was not timeshare. I even asked if the presentation would be held at 28 Guildford Road…she said No. On the morning of the presentation I was called by QVC and was given directions to the venue… and Yes it was at 28 Guilford Road!! Anyway as I had put aside the morning for this purpose.. I decided to attend. When I walked in I once again asked if this was timeshare or anything to do with vacations. Again the answer was No! Before the presentation started, the QVC presenter named the prizes that were on offer. Only 15 or so people or so had been invited for the day so we were guaranteed of winning today…and one of us would win the car.
    I won a midweek break and I quite frankly believe that that was what everybody won.

    After the presentation, we sat with the various sales people. I had no intention of buying and definately no intention of buying on the day.
    Somehow though the sales guy made good sense and I decided that I would buy. I did not want my partner to know that I was buying so made arrangement to contact the sales consultant later.

    Good thing I did. I researched QVC and availablity on HelloPeter and decided that I would not be going thru with this. Now that I have heard of Donn’s experience, I never want to hear from them ever again.

  9. Jack G Says:

    My parents walked into this trap and I need to get them out… Any advice? I just don’t have the time or money to fund a case like Donn’s. These people just won’t stop…